bloggie

sunday, october 22, 2017 1:49 am zst

woe is we

hyperlinkopotamus

Nitish kumar left a comment at 5:22 pm 10/21
192.168.1.1 Login left a comment at 1:14 pm 10/21
Wechat Messenger App left a comment at 3:09 pm 10/20
obat aborsi left a comment at 11:17 am 10/21
Intradote is also here
Jack William left a comment at 11:51 am 10/20
BlueStacks Download left a comment at 2:45 pm 10/18

Russian history in the classroom

Did you know that the majority of Russians think Stalin has played a positive role in Russian history? After reading this article, I see why: Omitting the past's darker chapters

Russians remember the Siege of Leningrad--a brutal, 872-day blockade of Russia's second-largest city by Nazi troops that killed 1.7 million people--as a dark, crucial moment in their history. Yet one of the most popular history textbooks in Russian classrooms casually distills the event into a mere four words.

"German troops blockaded Leningrad."

Glaring omissions abound in Nikita Zagladin's textbook, "History of Russia and the World in the 20th Century." The Holocaust is never mentioned. The book barely acknowledges the Gulag labor camps.

And it flits past Russia's 10-year conflict with separatists in Chechnya, reducing a pivotal episode in modern Russian history to seven paragraphs.

For some Russian academics, Zagladin's penchant for smoothing over the bumps in Russian history is precisely the reason his textbooks have become mainstays in Russian classrooms.

In recent years, authorities have increasingly sought to whip up patriotic fervor among Russians, often at the expense of illuminating Russian history's darker chapters.

Josef Stalin oversaw a murderous regime that killed millions of Russians. But with the country's celebration of the 60th anniversary of the defeat of Nazi Germany, the Georgian-born ruler has enjoyed a resurgence in popularity. The Siberian city of Mirny erected a statue of Stalin earlier this month, calling him "a great son of Russia who gave the people everything he had." The city of Orel recently asked the federal government for permission to change street names to honor Stalin.

It is in Russian classrooms, however, where authorities particularly want a renewed sense of national pride to take root.

When President
Vladimir Putin met with historians at the Russian State Library in late 2003, he stressed that history textbooks should "cultivate in young people a feeling of pride for one's history and one's country."

A month later, Putin asked the Russian Academy of Sciences to scrutinize the country's history textbooks "at the earliest possible date."

At the time, one of the most widely used history texts was Igor Dolutsky's "National History: 20th Century." For years, the book had been favored by teachers for its upfront discussion of sensitive topics, including Stalin's purges, Chechnya and anti-Semitism in Russia.

Dolutsky's textbook also did not shy away from talking about Putin, challenging students to discuss whether the former KGB colonel should be considered an authoritarian leader.

The Kremlin leader's comments were heeded by Education Ministry officials, who suddenly pulled Dolutsky's book from classrooms after having given it their endorsement for seven straight years.

"They said my book was `blackening' Russian history," Dolutsky said during a recent interview. "It was the first prohibition of a textbook in schools in 25 years."

The offending portions

Later, Dolutsky's publisher told him which historical references in the book irked authorities: Stalin's non-aggression pact with Hitler in 1939; Soviet occupation of the Baltic states; the execution of thousands of Polish officers by Russian intelligence agents at Katyn in 1940; Stalin's deportation of legions of Chechens to Kazakhstan in 1944.

"Basically, they were dissatisfied with chapters devoted to Stalin's regime and Putin's leadership," said Dolutsky, 51. "Sections that dealt with [Nikita] Khrushchev and [Mikhail] Gorbachev, they ignored."

Dmitry Ermoltsev, a Moscow teacher who has used Dolutsky's book, said he believes Kremlin attempts to polish the history taught in classrooms simply reflect a national reluctance to examine and learn from low points in Russian history.

"Russians don't like sharp criticism of their country's history--it makes them feel humiliated," Ermoltsev said. "Revising history and history books helps them overcome this discomfort. And Putin reacts to these signals from society."

Dolutsky, who teaches at a private school in Moscow, says his students have little appetite for lectures on human-rights abuses or Stalin's repressions. Recently, when he tried to rouse students into a discussion about the human toll that World War II took on the Soviet Union--26 million Soviet citizens died in the war--they appeared bored.

"Their reaction was, `Let it be 100 million--we don't care about that,'" Dolutsky said. When he explained the war's impact in terms of the number of tanks and fighter planes destroyed, his students sat up in their seats.

"That's what really impressed them," Dolutsky said. "They didn't care about human life, but they cared about equipment."

Should textbooks shame?

Author Zagladin's view of history in the classroom differs radically from Dolutsky's. He agrees with Putin--a history textbook should make a pupil feel proud about Russia. It shouldn't depress, and it shouldn't shame.

"If a young person finishes school and feels everything that happened in this country was bad, he'll get ready to emigrate," Zagladin said during a recent phone interview. "A textbook should provide a patriotic education.

"It's necessary to show Russian youths," Zagladin continued, "that industrial development during the Stalin era was successful, and that the repressions and terror during that era did not touch all of the population."

Zagladin acknowledged making mistakes in "The History of Russia and the World in the 20th Century."

He said he barely mentioned the Siege of Leningrad because he believed he didn't have enough space. In hindsight, he said, "that's my mistake."

He added he should have included material about the Holocaust: "I decided to delete it because, if I mentioned it, I would have had to mention other repressions, also in detail," Zagladin said. "And I didn't have enough space in this book."

Despite such omissions, Zagladin's book has fans. Irina Safanova, a teacher at School 818 in Moscow, called the textbook "a very calm book, which tries to avoid shocking or extreme remarks. It's a strong point of the book.

"History books should not condemn," Safanova said. "It's important to avoid provoking feelings of shame in students."

Zagladin's critics say Russian students do not need to be shamed, merely enlightened about history's darker chapters, especially in a country where the truth has been lacquered over for so many years.

"According to polls, the majority of the population still considers Stalin to have played a positive role in Russian history," said Yuri Samodurov, director of the Andrei Sakharov Museum. "And the problem here is, our schools don't do anything to change this attitude."

Posted by zorkmidden on Jun 01, 2005 1:00 pm

1 comment

#1 filmyink at 2:01 pm on Sep 08, 2017

recent comments

Do you know the JSC Result 2017 Publish date? Now a day, it is the popular and common question asks
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I
Since 2013, TECHAVERA Solutions is continuously providing quality training to students, working professionals, and to our corporate clients with an
thank you for taking the time to discuss this, I experience strongly that love and study more in this subject
This kind of message continually inspiring and that i favor to examine nice content material, so happy to find correct
This is quite evident show put up in results aren't that great as I expected but don't worry the board
Im no expert, but I believe you just made an excellent point. You certainly fully understand what youre speaking about,
Official [ Showbox App to stream movies ]/ and TV shows on your Android device. 100% Free ShowBox APK app
Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post.Keep up your work
Tours of Morocco can be modified and designed according to your requirements, [ custom essay writing service ]/ so
The 192.168.1.1 IP address is a default commonly used by Linksys routers. Get [ 192.168.l.l ]/ login & password, wireless
i'm satisfied to locate this publish Very useful for me, because it carries lot of information. I always choose to
The facts you've got posted could be very beneficial. The websites you've got referred become suitable. thank you for sharing...
obat tradisional Penyakit Jantung herbal sejagat jus manggis merupakan solusi yang paling tepat dalam menyembuhkan sakit jantung bengkak, karena bersifat
Obat Tradisional Penyakit Jantung Koroner herbal sejagat secara langsung mempunyai efek anti aterogenik yang bisa mencegah munculnya Sakit Jantung Koroner.
Saya konsumsi Jus Kulit Manggis Obat Tradisional Penyakit Kanker Paru Paru sebanyak tiga puluh ml setiap pagi hari, siang, dan
amazon Plus memiliki kandungan super anti-oksidan yang memiliki nama Xanthones. Menurut ahli yaitu, Dr.Raffi Paramawati,Msi kandungan xanthone dalam kulit manggis
Jus herbal sejagat telah terbukti mampu memberantas penyakit kanker limfoma hodgkin. [ obat herbal kanker limfoma hodgkin ]/ Jawaban
Sudah bisa disimpulkan dengan mengkonsumsi Obat Tradisonal Kanker Rahim herbal sejagat sama seperti kita tidak memberi peluang pada sel kanker
Hasil survey dari banyak negara menjelaskan bahwa di dalam kulit buah manggis terkandung xanthone yang mempunyai antioksidan, yang bisa mengobati
Ciri-ciri Penyakit asma dapat kita kenali dengan pertanda di awalnya dengan adanya keluhan flu rasa berat dirasakan di dada.
[ Jual Obat Aborsi ]/ , [ Obat Aborsi ]/ , [ Obat Penggugur Kandungan ]/ ,
This is Very Nice Post Fantastic material and amazing article.I most want to say that you are doing a great
Superb Information, I really appreciated with it, This is fine to read and valuable pro potential, I really bookmark it,
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I

home

this & that

bloggie pulse: circulation
last 15 minutes:
0
last hour:
0
last 24 hours:
1
bloggie pulse: comments
since midnite:
0
last 24 hours:
26
in our lifetime:
9886