discarded lies - tuesday, february 9, 2010 10:21 am zst
We can always panic tomorrow.
zorkmidden
Olmert, gadol alecha
As the IDF is trying to rescue Gilad Shalit, Yossi Klein Halevi explains why Israel's attack on Gaza isn't enough.
Resuming assassinations against Hamas's political echelon is, of course, a declaration of war against the Hamas regime. But given its official sanctioning of kidnapping, Hamas has already declared war against Israel. Hamas's adoption of the tactics of Al Qaeda in Iraq comes as no surprise. After the killing of Zarqawi, Hamas issued a statement mourning his death and urging continued "resistance," thereby making the Hamas regime the world's only openly pro-Al Qaeda government. Unfortunately, the international media missed the significance of that moment.

That lapse in media judgment is worth recalling in the coming days, when much of the media will be presenting the "prisoners' document"--a set of demands drawn up by Hamas and Fatah members imprisoned in Israel--as a historic Hamas concession, offering "tacit" recognition of Israel. In fact, the document does nothing of the sort. Nowhere does the document recognize the right of Israel to exist. Instead, it calls for Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 borders, followed by the "right" of Palestinian refugees to resettle in Israel and demographically overwhelm the Jewish state. The prisoners' document, in other words, is a plan for the phased destruction of Israel--precisely why Hamas can endorse it.
We've already seen the headlines, "Hamas implicitly recognizes Israel", but the media conveniently omits the rest of the details.
filed under the mess on Jun 28, 2006 10:39 am
31 comments, latest by Earl at 3:50 am 6/29
#1 Matt at 11:14 am on Jun 28, 2006
The claim goes that, by referring to the '67 lines as a boundary for their state, they recognise that Israel is on the other side of that line. As if this shitty document will undo the apparent tradition of self-delusion ("Israel? No such thing.").

By the by...

'Alecha'? I'm not sure what it means, but if it is a noun, you want 'alecha gadol'. 'Alecha' sounds feminine, too, soo probably 'alecha gadola'.

/anal
#2 zorkmidden at 11:22 am on Jun 28, 2006
Yell at the Jewish person who wrote the graffiti, I just copied it :-)
#3 cba γβα גבא ابت вба at 11:27 am on Jun 28, 2006
"alecha" means "on you" (although in a phrase it can't be translated literally) and is masculine singular. The feminine equivalent is "alayich."

The plural is "aleichem" and I'm sure you're familiar with the phrase "shalom aleichem" ("peace be upon you")
#4 zorkmidden at 11:29 am on Jun 28, 2006
When I wrote the post, I had access to the whole article. Now I click on the link and it asks me for registration. The bugmenot login is not working for this site and I can't find where I got the whole article.
#5 Matt at 11:35 am on Jun 28, 2006
No, I hadn't heard of it. That said, I'm still learning past tense, so...

Is it a prefix, or is it just anglified from this:

על לך
#6 Matt at 11:36 am on Jun 28, 2006

Yell at the Jewish person who wrote the graffiti, I just copied it :-)



When I know what I'm talking about, I'll yell at them...

#7 Maine's Michael at 11:37 am on Jun 28, 2006
log in using

clarkgb
gable
#8 Ed Mahmoud abu Lets Make the GOMEX look like a dehydrated man's toilet at 11:40 am on Jun 28, 2006
#3 cba γβα גבא ابت вба
"alecha" means "on you" (although in a phrase it can't be translated literally) and is masculine singular. The feminine equivalent is "alayich."

The plural is "aleichem" and I'm sure you're familiar with the phrase "shalom aleichem" ("peace be upon you")



IIRC, the Wiggles do that song sometimes on their TV show.
#9 cba γβα גבא ابت вба at 11:42 am on Jun 28, 2006
That's kinda the source of the word. "Al" is "on" (El Al kinda means "to [towards] up there").

For example, the expression "me-al u-mi-ever" means "over and above" [as in over and above the line of duty, doing more than is expected].

Reminds me of the time, about a year after I'd arrived in Israel, when I took a phone message for a co-worker. I noticed him (and other colleagues) laughing at my note. Turn out that although I'd intended to write "Sarah called and wants you to call her back [le-hitkasher eleyha]" but I'd written it with an ayin [le-hitkasher aleyha], whch could be understood to mean "to make contact on top of her."

I never made that mistake again.
#10 zorkmidden at 11:42 am on Jun 28, 2006
#7 Maine's Michael
log in using

clarkgb
gable

That didn't work for me, either.
#11 solus rex at 11:53 am on Jun 28, 2006

That lapse in media judgment is worth recalling in the coming days

I don't think it's a lapse in judgement. The media is simply on Hamas's side.

#12 joem at 12:13 pm on Jun 28, 2006

We've already seen the headlines, "Hamas implicitly recognizes Israel", but the media conveniently omits the rest of the details.

Have you seen Camera's article on this: Prisoners' Document: Peace Plan or “Phased Plan”?


Boker Tov, Boulder had a furious piece about this yesterday, too.

#13 zorkmidden at 12:20 pm on Jun 28, 2006
joem, I hadn't read the Camera article, I see they're saying pretty much what I'm thinking.

I don't think it's a lapse in media judgment, either. I think everyone's going to push this document as "see, Hamas wants peace and accepts Israel".
#14 annie at 12:24 pm on Jun 28, 2006
#4 zorkmidden
When I wrote the post, I had access to the whole article. Now I click on the link and it asks me for registration. The bugmenot login is not working for this site and I can't find where I got the whole article.

Zorkie, Will this help you? I must have registered long ago. I tried my own "standard" name and password I use for "friendly" newspapers and it worked. This is the print-friendly page.

If it doesn't work, shall I post the whole thing here?
#15 annie at 12:25 pm on Jun 28, 2006
Matt, CBA, As to the grammar lesson going on here, "gadol alecha" is colloquial (but grammatically correct) Hebrew for "the job is too big for you".

The words literally mean "big on you", e.g. that coat is big on you = hame'il hazeh gadol alecha.

(CBA, LOL at your faux pas!) :-D
#16 joem at 12:31 pm on Jun 28, 2006
annie, that didn't work for me.

gadol alecha? I think it should be gadol mimcha ("bigger than you").
#17 zorkmidden at 12:31 pm on Jun 28, 2006
Thanks annie, but that didn't work for me either :-) Sure, if you want. I just wanted to show Matt the gadol alecha so he could read the meaning.

Efraim Halevy:

“The real question is whether the Palestine national movement has the power to create a structure of command, control and viable governance,” Halevy states. “Are they capable of setting up a system of governance?” While Halevy won’t predict the outcome, his analysis is that Hamas is now on the horns of a dilemma about the direction they will take. “All timetables have changed,” Halevy asserts, noting that the ruling party would now be pushed to go one way or the other because a faction had chosen to instigate the well-planned tunnel incursion into Israeli territory. “We’ll see all this unfold in the next 24-48 hours,” he predicts.

Halevy paints a scenario where Khalad Mashal, the Damascus based head of Hamas’ military wing could triumph over the so-called civil wing. There’s a “real possibility Mashal will succeed in leading Hamas into a spiral of destruction over this issue,” he asserts. If that should occur, the future will be an even greater question mark than ever, Halevy says.

But the former intelligence head posits that should the Gaza and Ramallah Hamasniks “get it together and overcome the threat from Damascus, Hamas could become a viable partner for negotiations with Israel.” If they resolve the kidnapping, “we’ll be in a new ball game,” Halevy asserts. At that point, Hamas will have some degree of credibility and if they show that they will adhere to some basic norms of how a responsible government acts, it will be possible to deal with them, Halevy maintains.



#18 joem at 12:33 pm on Jun 28, 2006
(heh - I wrote that before I saw #15. You and your colloquialisms :)
#19 annie at 12:38 pm on Jun 28, 2006
#18 joem
(heh - I wrote that before I saw #15. You and your colloquialisms :)

LOL! You just gotta move here and get with the lingo. You dig?

I once went to sheva brachot where the chatan's brother dressed up as a camel - that was hilarious in itself - and sang a song "ki gamal alai".*

We were in stitches. :-D

*to ruin the joke by explaining: that is from a verse in Psalms meaning "for He has saved me". But a gamal is a camel, so it can also mean "for there is a camel on me". Geddit? Oh, never mind...
#20 joem at 12:39 pm on Jun 28, 2006
LOL!
#21 annie at 12:42 pm on Jun 28, 2006
OK, I won't post the whole article because it's quite long, but here are the relevant bits about the graffiti in zorkie's title:

Our obsession with hostages is a tactical weakness but a strategic strength. It allows terrorists a stunning psychological advantage: With a single random kidnapping, they hold an entire society emotionally hostage. Strategically, though, hostage-taking only strengthens Israeli resolve.

And resolve is precisely what the public now expects of its government. So far, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has responded well. He began by issuing two policy guidelines in dealing with the hostage crisis. The first is that Israel won't negotiate over Gilad's release and won't exchange prisoners. The second is that Hamas leaders--"political" as well as "military"--will be held personally accountable for the fate of Gilad.

If Olmert's government hopes to retain its credibility among Israelis, it needs to maintain those two principles.

snip

After the withdrawal, Israelis expected the government to enforce a policy of zero-tolerance for Palestinian attacks emanating from Gaza, even for attacks that didn't cause fatalities. Instead, the government responded unevenly, often ignoring rocket attacks that caused no damage.

Many Israelis see Hamas's raid on an Israeli military post within the 1967 borders as a result of the weakness Israel has projected. In yesterday's letters column in the daily Maariv, for example, the hardline consensus was almost unanimous. "We told you so," wrote one reader who identified himself as "right wing." "Why doesn't Israel shut off electricity and water to Gaza?" demanded another reader. "Enough words, it's time to act," insisted a third.


snip

Driving on the Jerusalem-Tel Aviv highway, I saw this graffiti: "Olmert, gadol alecha"--which roughly translates as, "Olmert, the job is bigger than you are." For Olmert to disprove that growing suspicion among Israelis, he must commit himself to the destruction of the Hamas regime. Sooner or later, Israel will have no choice but to adopt that policy. The only question is whether Olmert will still be prime minister when that happens.

#22 evariste at 12:49 pm on Jun 28, 2006
Thanks, annie! "Olmert, the job is bigger than you are"-I hope the graffiti artist is proven wrong, but I suspect that truer words have never been spray-painted on the side of a highway.
#23 Matt at 1:35 pm on Jun 28, 2006
Ahh, cool. Okay.

Turn out that although I'd intended to write "Sarah called and wants you to call her back [le-hitkasher eleyha]" but I'd written it with an ayin [le-hitkasher aleyha], whch could be understood to mean "to make contact on top of her."



LOL!

#24 cba γβα גבא ابت вба at 5:04 pm on Jun 28, 2006
#15 annie
Matt, CBA, As to the grammar lesson going on here, "gadol alecha" is colloquial (but grammatically correct) Hebrew for "the job is too big for you".

The words literally mean "big on you", e.g. that coat is big on you = hame'il hazeh gadol alecha.

(CBA, LOL at your faux pas!) :-D
Thanks, I figured it had to be a colloquialism I wasn't familiar with with which I wasn't familiar (I haven't lived there for 18 years and I'm waaaay behind on the slang).

As for my faux pas... yes, it was pretty funny. Almost as funny as the time my husband (then my fiance) thought he'd told the security guard he was coming to visit his fiancee (erusa) but in fact he'd said asura [forbidden].

And the funniest part? "Wow, and he still let me in!" exclaimed my beloved.
#25 zorkmidden at 5:08 pm on Jun 28, 2006
LOL!!
#26 cba γβα גבא ابت вба at 5:11 pm on Jun 28, 2006
I fed the hippo, but you must read today's Dry Bones.
#27 zorkmidden at 5:16 pm on Jun 28, 2006
Excellent.
#28 cba γβα גבא ابت вба at 5:22 pm on Jun 28, 2006

I once went to sheva brachot where the chatan's brother dressed up as a camel - that was hilarious in itself - and sang a song "ki gamal alai".*

annie, that's too funny!

One of the funniest things I saw on TV in Israel occurred on a very lame game show (I don't remember what it was called, and I think it didn't last very long). The panel consisted of various well-known people (I only remember Ofra Haza, z"l) and they were given the start of a sentence to complete.

This was around Chanukah the year Israel captured Mordechai Va'anunu, and one of the sentences began, "The USA knows we have nuclear weapons, but they don't know that we don't have... [<HebrewHebrew> sheh ayn lanu...]"

Most of the responses were very lame (the main reason the show ended), but one guy said, "sheh ayn lanu rishut lehishtamesh bahem, eylah lirot'am bilvad" which is part of one of the prayers over the Chanukah candles and means, "we are not allowed to use them, but only to look at them."

It brought the house down.

#29 annie at 10:59 pm on Jun 28, 2006
CBA - that's hilarious! :-D Both your hubby's remark (LMAO!) and that game show (I don't remember that but Israeli TV is usually not very memorable...)
#30 Matt at 3:25 am on Jun 29, 2006
Earl, have a look at the photo in this article.
#31 Earl at 3:50 am on Jun 29, 2006
#30 Matt

Well, better equipped, certainly. Although those skinny little legs aren't those of the big lads that the Canucks, Brits and Yanks send in to clean up a problem ;) (of course, these Israeli troops may well be accountants, orthodontists and code-writers called up from the reserves- all the more remarkable).

Hunter-killer teams are well and good as a micro-exercise. But, to paraphrase Rummie, "can we kill the jihadis faster than the madrassahs can produce them?" Here, the Hamas hydra will merely grow new heads and Israel has then created a slew of new pali martyr/prisoners, with their attendant hostage-swap value and incarceration costs.

Let me give you a farm analogy from my experience. Coyote(s) appear and kill sheep- sometimes sport kills where the lamb is not actually eaten. Dogs are run after the coyotes and the coyotes are shot. But to kill off the coyotes in a given area, one kills the bitch in the den... and I reckon the bitch that spawns this evil, existential threat to Israel resides in Iran and Syria.
shrink↑ | ↓expand
search & handy links
redecorate bloggie!
threads you've been on
hot threads today
by our guest authors
hippocampus
day-by-day archives
category archives
link lists
oh faq!
colophon
 
recent comments:
Earl
[ #3 ]/ evariste: COTD
franco en america del sur
What the hell is a Jewish guy doing with a Christian first name and a Muslim last name?
Christine Keeler
[ #31 ]/ Queequeg: Peter was a wonderful man albeit a little strange. He used to ask
Lewis
Plaster's not really all that wonderful. Fairly soundproof, yes, but wonderful? No.
Pastorius
Rand's attack on "altruism" gives her away. Any Christian who can hear her critique of altruism and still believe the
franco en america del sur
He tore out all that wonderful plaster just so that he could use his cell inside his house????
Pastorius
I can't tell you how many times I've seen Philosophy professors go off the rails. I had one Professor whose
Pastorius
_ I´m amazed that so many consider themselves simultaneously "Randian" and "Christian". _ As a Christian, I'm
Lewis
[ #12 ]/ evariste #11 Lewis I read enough Kant in college
evariste
I really liked his joke about how it's a little-known fact that the original Boston Tea Party was also for-profit.
evariste
Cool!
Salome
I'm biting, and thank you! I wish I had more time to devote to this. As you're well aware, this
Pastorius
Though I do like Palin, in general, I thought this bit was hilarious.
evariste
[ #11 ]/ Lewis I read enough Kant in college to have an honest lack of respect
Lewis
I read enough Kant in college to have an honest lack of respect for his philosophy. Now don't get
levi from queens
[ #6 ]/ franco en america del sur: It would be good if all medical providers posted prices at
evariste
This thread is blatant Salomé bait, let's see if she bites. She has really good style.
evariste
I have a great natural sartorial style which I consider simultaneously very elegant and casual, but it's quite unrefined because
evariste
' I have lived my entire life blissfully unaware that a conversation has been taking place around me that
Lewis
#187 Marwa She didn't mention just any old Arab country, now did she? She specifically said "somewhere like
 
the hyperlinkopotamus:
evariste-tue 9:22 am (5 comments)
evariste-tue 9:05 am (2 comments)
evariste-tue 8:38 am (3 comments)
evariste-tue 8:14 am (6 comments)
evariste-tue 7:53 am (1 comments)
evariste-tue 7:27 am (1 comments)
evariste-tue 6:55 am (5 comments)
annie-tue 5:42 am (4 comments)
evariste-tue 4:36 am (16 comments)
evariste-tue 4:31 am (3 comments)
evariste-mon 10:00 pm (14 comments)
Lady of Shalott-mon 6:32 pm (8 comments)
evariste-mon 6:08 pm (7 comments)
evariste-mon 5:02 pm (30 comments)
evariste-mon 4:30 pm (34 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 3:54 pm (7 comments)
evariste-mon 3:52 pm (9 comments)
evariste-mon 3:01 pm (2 comments)
franco en america del sur-mon 12:25 pm (6 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 12:14 pm (9 comments)
browse previous hippo links in the archive
 
Bloggies Of Our Lives
Season One
Season Two
Season Three
Special Guest Episodes
 
Ferkakta
Ferkakta Timeshare Presentation
Postcard from Ferkakta
Ferkakta Is Open For Business
Lord of the Banned: An Epic Trilogy In Three Parts

Ferkakta Games
Codename:Ferkakta Hill
Ferkakta By Night
Shipwrecked
House
 
vital signs
Circulation
last 15 minutes:90
last hour:335
last 24 hours:4533
Comments
since midnight:81
last 24 hours:258
in our lifetime:723012