discarded lies - hyperlinkopotamus - tuesday, february 9, 2010 6:16 am zst
brought to you by the makers of Bloggie
papijoe
Wesley Smith: Right to Die Movement is about Euthanasia, Not Compassion
filed on May 02, 2006 7:50 am
1 comment
#1 papijoe at 7:53 am on May 02, 2006

The Sunday Times Magazine (London) reported that Dignitas' founder, Ludwig Minelli, plans to create sort of a Starbucks for suicide: a chain of death centers "to end the lives of people with illnesses and mental conditions such as chronic depression."

Minelli believes that all suicidal people should be given information about the best way to kill themselves, and, according to the Times story, "if they choose to die, they should be helped to do it properly." Dignitas admits to having assisted the suicides of many people who were not terminally ill. As Minelli succinctly put it, "We never say no."

The story about Minelli illuminates a deep ideological belief within the euthanasia movement: that we own our bodies, and thus, determining the time, manner, and method of our own deaths, for whatever reason, is a basic human right.

That is certainly how one of the other superstars of the international euthanasia movement, the Australian physician Phillip Nitschke, sees it. Nitschke travels the world presenting how-to-commit-suicide clinics. Several years ago he was paid thousands of dollars by the Hemlock Society (now merged into the assisted suicide advocacy group Compassion and Choices) to create a suicide concoction made from common household ingredients (a formula he calls the "Peaceful Pill").

Like Minelli, Nitschke is straightforward about his goals. In a 2001 interview, National Review Online asked him who should qualify for the Peaceful Pill. He responded:

My personal position is that if we believe that there is a right to life, then we must accept that people have a right to dispose of that life whenever they want . . . So all people qualify, not just those with the training, knowledge, or resources to find out how to "give away" their life. And someone needs to provide this knowledge, training, or resource necessary to anyone who wants it, including the depressed, the elderly bereaved, [and] the troubled teen.


Nitschke and Minelli's position has a large constituency among euthanasia believers. Indeed, over the years, the movement has left many telltale signs that assisted suicide is not intended ultimately to be restricted to the imminently dying.

shrink↑ | ↓expand
search & handy links
redecorate bloggie!
threads you've been on
hot threads today
by our guest authors
hippocampus
day-by-day archives
category archives
link lists
oh faq!
colophon
 
recent comments:
franco en america del sur
My former coworker who is marooned in a hotel this week, needs this, too.
franco en america del sur
At those times when I actually get the urge to eat their food, I´m always happy to go to McDonalds.
evariste
Your comment was very apropos, franco—Rand's hatred for Kant was exactly as idiotic and baseless as Lévy's approval of a
evariste
A passionate, obsessive hatred for Kant which was mindless and ignorant. Along with plenty of other philosophers whose work she
evariste
All parents of teenagers desperately need this.
franco en america del sur
Aridog - That´s good to know about "real" plaster. My apartment is built of that, I didn´t realize that
franco en america del sur
Sadly, Ayn Rand could not reach herself for comment. (For those who are not familiar, Rand had a passionate,
packen
LOL. Does Israel hold the patent? This could be a huge money maker.
annie
Srsly. ' JERUSALEM (AFP) - Israel's foot soldiers are getting new odour-free socks that can be worn for
Rune
Let fall what can’t stand. The nations need to go bankrupt to teach them some financial discipline.
packen
Great post, jau jau. It reminded me of a German deli on Austin Street in Forest Hills--the complete opposite of
evariste
Crap, I named and shamed the wrong group. It was Amnesty International in my link, too. I'll fix it.
cba γβα גבא ابت вба
[ Amnesty International too ]/ . Harry's place has several follow-up posts, if you're interested.
evariste
' When France’s most dashing philosopher took aim at Immanuel Kant in his latest book, calling him “raving mad”
evariste
' There is a vital role for groups like HRW and Amnesty to play in the world. Properly understood,
Aridog
[ #15 ]/ franco en america del sur My high school English teacher used to smoke as
Aridog
[ #12 ]/ jau jau I don't think it is becoming a matriarchal society so much as
Aridog
[ #12 ]/ packen Oh yeah, the reason I'm not in a hurry to buy a laptop.
Badboy Recovered
[ #4 ]/ franco en america del sur So how come the Italians don´t get lumped with
jau jau
I would love to have this woman as governor!
 
the hyperlinkopotamus:
annie-tue 5:42 am (4 comments)
evariste-tue 4:36 am (4 comments)
evariste-tue 4:31 am (3 comments)
evariste-mon 10:00 pm (7 comments)
Lady of Shalott-mon 6:32 pm (7 comments)
evariste-mon 6:08 pm (7 comments)
evariste-mon 5:02 pm (25 comments)
evariste-mon 4:30 pm (32 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 3:54 pm (5 comments)
evariste-mon 3:52 pm (9 comments)
evariste-mon 3:01 pm (2 comments)
franco en america del sur-mon 12:25 pm (6 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 12:14 pm (9 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 11:58 am (16 comments)
zorkmidden-mon 11:47 am (4 comments)
Thousand Sons-mon 8:32 am (3 comments)
Nodrog-mon 8:31 am (3 comments)
packen-mon 5:39 am (3 comments)
evariste-mon 12:28 am (9 comments)
evariste-mon 12:23 am (3 comments)
browse previous hippo links in the archive
 
Bloggies Of Our Lives
Season One
Season Two
Season Three
Special Guest Episodes
 
Ferkakta
Ferkakta Timeshare Presentation
Postcard from Ferkakta
Ferkakta Is Open For Business
Lord of the Banned: An Epic Trilogy In Three Parts

Ferkakta Games
Codename:Ferkakta Hill
Ferkakta By Night
Shipwrecked
House
 
vital signs
Circulation
last 15 minutes:93
last hour:311
last 24 hours:4181
Comments
since midnight:19
last 24 hours:210
in our lifetime:722950